Regulation of Bankruptcy Law in Indonesia

Oct 13, 2025 by pynkocean.com 38 views

Introduction

Bankruptcy is often viewed as a negative and final verdict in the business world, bringing with it a range of negative assumptions and stigmas. However, there are principles that may not be widely known by the public, namely the principle of commercial exit from financial distress. This principle explains that bankruptcy can be a commercial solution to get out of debt problems that burden the debtor. One way to apply it is to apply for a voluntary bankruptcy. In this case, PT. Mandala Airlines is a concrete example in which the principle is applied, after being declared bankrupt by the decision of the Central Jakarta Commercial Court with Number 48/Pdt.Sus.Pailit/2014/PN.Niaga.JKT.Pst.

Background of the Case

PT. Mandala Airlines submitted a bankruptcy request because of prolonged financial difficulties due to intense competition in the aviation industry in Indonesia. The company's financial difficulties were caused by external factors such as very tight competition, which shows that bankruptcy conditions are not the result of poor management, but the situation that can be faced by many companies in the same sector. In this thesis, it will be discussed about the regulation of bankruptcy law in Indonesia, the principle of commercial exit from financial distress in the context of bankruptcy limited liability company, as well as its application in the bankruptcy decision of PT. Mandala Airlines.

Regulation of Bankruptcy Law in Indonesia

The regulation of bankruptcy law in Indonesia refers to Law Number 37 of 2004 concerning bankruptcy and delay of debt payment obligations. This law implies the ease of putting the legal subjects involved in the debt collective process. However, in the context of PT. Mandala Airlines, although they submit an application based on the principle of commercial exit from financial distress, this law does not fully accommodate the approach. The law focuses on the liquidation of assets and the distribution of proceeds to creditors, rather than providing a mechanism for debtors to restructure their debt and continue their operations.

The Principle of Commercial Exit from Financial Distress

Further analysis shows that the principle of commercial exit from financial distress must be seen as a strategic step that can provide an opportunity for debtors to improve their financial conditions, not just as a path to bankruptcy. This principle is based on the idea that bankruptcy can be a commercial solution to get out of debt problems that burden the debtor. In the case of PT. Mandala Airlines, the financial difficulties they face are caused by external factors such as very tight competition. This shows that bankruptcy conditions are not the result of poor management, but the situation that can be faced by many companies in the same sector.

Application of the Principle in the Context of Indonesian Law

The application of this principle in the context of Indonesian law is very important to note. Considering that this principle can help the debtor to restructure its debt and continue the company's operations, it is time for changes in Law Number 37 of 2004 to be more responsive to dynamic market conditions. This can be done by introducing a more flexible mechanism in the bankruptcy process, providing space for companies to rise again instead of being trapped in negative bankruptcy stigma.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the application of the principle of commercial exit from financial distress in bankruptcy law in Indonesia, especially in the case of PT. Mandala Airlines, shows the need for evaluation and reform of existing regulations. By making proper changes, it is hoped that the bankruptcy system can further support economic growth and provide a second chance for the debtor to rise from their financial difficulties.

Recommendations

Based on the analysis of the case of PT. Mandala Airlines, the following recommendations are made:

The government should review and revise Law Number 37 of 2004 to make it more responsive to dynamic market conditions.
A more flexible mechanism should be introduced in the bankruptcy process to provide space for companies to restructure their debt and continue their operations.
The principle of commercial exit from financial distress should be recognized as a strategic step that can provide an opportunity for debtors to improve their financial conditions.

Limitations of the Study

This study has several limitations that should be noted:

The study is based on a single case study, which may not be representative of all cases of bankruptcy in Indonesia.
The study focuses on the principle of commercial exit from financial distress, but does not explore other factors that may contribute to bankruptcy.
The study is based on secondary data, which may not be comprehensive or up-to-date.

Future Research Directions

Future research should focus on the following areas:

Exploring the application of the principle of commercial exit from financial distress in other industries and sectors.
Investigating the impact of the principle on the financial performance of companies.
Developing a more comprehensive framework for understanding the causes and consequences of bankruptcy.

Conclusion

Q: What is the principle of commercial exit from financial distress?

A: The principle of commercial exit from financial distress is a concept that explains that bankruptcy can be a commercial solution to get out of debt problems that burden the debtor. This principle is based on the idea that bankruptcy can provide an opportunity for debtors to improve their financial conditions, not just as a path to bankruptcy.

Q: How does the principle of commercial exit from financial distress apply to PT. Mandala Airlines?

A: PT. Mandala Airlines submitted a bankruptcy request because of prolonged financial difficulties due to intense competition in the aviation industry in Indonesia. The company's financial difficulties were caused by external factors such as very tight competition, which shows that bankruptcy conditions are not the result of poor management, but the situation that can be faced by many companies in the same sector.

Q: What is the significance of the principle of commercial exit from financial distress in the context of Indonesian law?

A: The application of this principle in the context of Indonesian law is very important to note. Considering that this principle can help the debtor to restructure its debt and continue the company's operations, it is time for changes in Law Number 37 of 2004 to be more responsive to dynamic market conditions. This can be done by introducing a more flexible mechanism in the bankruptcy process, providing space for companies to rise again instead of being trapped in negative bankruptcy stigma.

Q: What are the limitations of the study?

A: This study has several limitations that should be noted:

The study is based on a single case study, which may not be representative of all cases of bankruptcy in Indonesia.
The study focuses on the principle of commercial exit from financial distress, but does not explore other factors that may contribute to bankruptcy.
The study is based on secondary data, which may not be comprehensive or up-to-date.

Q: What are the future research directions?

A: Future research should focus on the following areas:

Exploring the application of the principle of commercial exit from financial distress in other industries and sectors.
Investigating the impact of the principle on the financial performance of companies.
Developing a more comprehensive framework for understanding the causes and consequences of bankruptcy.

Q: What are the recommendations for the government and regulatory bodies?

A: Based on the analysis of the case of PT. Mandala Airlines, the following recommendations are made:

The government should review and revise Law Number 37 of 2004 to make it more responsive to dynamic market conditions.
A more flexible mechanism should be introduced in the bankruptcy process to provide space for companies to restructure their debt and continue their operations.
The principle of commercial exit from financial distress should be recognized as a strategic step that can provide an opportunity for debtors to improve their financial conditions.

Q: What are the implications of the study for businesses and entrepreneurs?

A: The study has several implications for businesses and entrepreneurs:

The principle of commercial exit from financial distress can provide a second chance for debtors to rise from their financial difficulties.
The study highlights the importance of understanding the causes and consequences of bankruptcy.
The study provides insights into the application of the principle in the context of Indonesian law.

Q: What are the implications of the study for policymakers and regulatory bodies?

A: The study has several implications for policymakers and regulatory bodies:

The study highlights the need for evaluation and reform of existing regulations.
The study provides insights into the application of the principle in the context of Indonesian law.
The study recommends changes in Law Number 37 of 2004 to make it more responsive to dynamic market conditions.